---

name: formatting-audits description: > Design document review format definition with 100-point scoring system. Provides quality evaluation criteria, scoring items, and pass/fail logic for SOW/Spec documents. Combined with confidence markers (✓/→/?) to clarify evaluation evidence. Triggers: SOW review, Spec review, document review, design review, ドキュメントレビュー, 設計レビュー, 90 points, scoring, grading, 品質評価, スコアリング, 合否判定. allowed-tools: Read, Grep, Glob user-invocable: false

Review Format - Design Document Scoring

100-point scoring format for evaluating SOW/Spec document quality.

Scoring System

Item	Score	Focus	Criteria
Accuracy	0-25	Facts vs inferences	✓/→/? markers, evidence paths
Completeness	0-25	Coverage	Testable criteria, risks, dependencies
Relevance	0-25	Alignment	Goals ↔ solutions, scope, YAGNI
Actionability	0-25	Implementability	Specific steps, feasibility, next actions

Judgment Criteria

Score	Judgment	Action
90-100	PASS	Proceed to next phase
70-89	CONDITIONAL	Re-review after fixes
0-69	FAIL	Major revision needed

Score Guidelines

Score Range	Quality Level
23-25	Excellent - All claims have evidence
18-22	Acceptable - Most claims verified
13-17	Needs work - Multiple gaps
0-12	Insufficient - Major issues

Output Format

## 📋 Design Document Review Result

### Total Score: {total}/100 {✅/⚠️/❌}

| Item          | Score | Marker |
| ------------- | ----- | ------ |
| Accuracy      | /25   | ✓/→/?  |
| Completeness  | /25   | ✓/→/?  |
| Relevance     | /25   | ✓/→/?  |
| Actionability | /25   | ✓/→/?  |

### 🔗 SOW ↔ Spec Consistency

| Check                    | Status |
| ------------------------ | ------ |
| Acceptance Criteria → FR | ✓/→/?  |
| Risks → Mitigations      | ✓/→/?  |
| Dependencies             | ✓/→/?  |
| Test Coverage            | ✓/→/?  |

### 📝 Requested Modifications

🔴 Required: [list]
🟡 Recommended: [list]

### Next Action

✅ PASS: /code
⚠️ CONDITIONAL: Fix and re-review
❌ FAIL: Re-plan with /think

References

Related Skills

• reviewing-readability - Readability review skill

Related Agents

• sow-spec-reviewer - SOW/Spec verification agent

Used by Commands

• /think - SOW/Spec generation
• /audit - Code review orchestration